When To Seek Advice Following An Accident At School

Sophie Davies
school children writing

Table of Contents

Autumn is upon us and it’s the start of another academic year. With a 7 year old boy recently being reported in the press as Britain’s youngest skydiver, traditionally risky activities are becoming increasingly accessible to children. But when it comes to school life, can children have a bit of rough and tumble in the playground or does our legal system wrap pupils in cotton wool, allowing the ‘compensation culture’ to cross the school gates? Victoria Gallanders investigates.

It’s a fact of life that children will sometimes get injured at school. For many adults a grazed knee in the playground was just part and parcel of growing up, and the courts too appreciate that children are bound to have some minor injuries when at school. However, sadly not all school injuries are minor. This was reinforced this month when a school in Boston was fined £16,500 by the HSE after a 16 year old girl lost most of her fingers to burns sustained from plaster of Paris in an art lesson.

Three common scenarios when a school pupil may suffer injury through no fault of their own are when they are injured by another child who was insufficiently supervised, injured when using school equipment, or injured in poorly maintained grounds. Each of these situations is looked at in turn below:


It is well established that schools and teachers should ensure that pupils are safe at school. One aspect of this is supervising children to prevent them from injuring themselves and one another. The courts accept that as children get older they will need less supervision, except when participating in more risky activities when a higher level of supervision is required. Similarly, as children get older they are more aware of the consequences of their actions, with the result that even if poorly supervised, blame may be apportioned to the wrongdoing child themselves as well as the school.

So when will a school be liable for insufficiently supervising children? The answer is that there are no hard and fast rules for this and cases tend to turn on their facts. For example, in Palmer v Cornwall County Council (2009) a year 9 pupil was hit in the eye by a rock thrown by a fellow year 9 pupil during their lunch break. The accident occurred on school fields and there was only one dinner lady supervising approximately 300 pupils from years 7 – 10. The Court of Appeal found that to have just one supervisor watching over the year 7 and 8 pupils and glancing at the year 9 and 10 pupils was negligent and the local authority was therefore ordered to pay compensation to the injured child. However, this is contrasted with Pettican v Enfield LBC (1970) where a child’s eye was poked by a piece of chalk when children were fooling around during indoor break time on a wet day. Although teachers had to supervise more than one classroom, the local authority was found not to be liable. Liability therefore depends on the individual circumstances of each case.

A school or local authority’s duty to supervise children can also extend to before and after the school day. For example, when children are waiting outside school for lessons to start and making their way home in the afternoon they can be particularly vulnerable to passing motorists. In July 2009 The Hackney Gazette reported an all too familiar story of a pupil who broke his shoulder and arm in a road traffic accident with a motorcyclist outside his school. Whilst liability for such accidents may sometimes lay with the motorist, schools and local authorities should also ensure that children are supervised appropriately outside the school gates.

School equipment

Schools should also ensure that pupils are reasonably safe when using school equipment. Therefore if a child is injured when using defective or unsuitable playground apparatus or sports equipment, the school may be liable. Schools should make sure that play equipment is suitable for the ages of pupils at the school. So, for example, climbing frames should not be too high for younger children, and there should be soft tarmac or bark chippings below them to minimise injury if a child were to fall.

School equipment also covers desks, scissors, test tubes…in fact most school property which a child uses in the course of a school day. Again, when determining whether equipment is suitable, the court will look at a child’s age. For example, in Butt v Cambridgeshire and Ely CC (1970) a child was poked in the eye with a pair of scissors. The class was of 9 and 10 year olds and the local authority was not found liable. In contrast however, the local authority in Black v Kent City Council (1983) was found liable when a seven year old was poked in the eye by sharp scissors, as blunt ended scissors would have been more suitable for this age group. Therefore if a child is injured by unsuitable or faulty equipment, they may be entitled to compensation but again the case will turn on its facts.

Poorly maintained grounds

Finally, many school injuries result from trips, slips and falls. Under the Occupiers Liability Act 1957, schools must take reasonable care to ensure that pupils are reasonably safe when on school premises. This means that if they trip over a raised pavement slab, or a divot in a playing field, and the school had not acted reasonably in not spotting and remedying the defect, the child could be entitled to compensation. When considering what is reasonable, the courts accept that a child would not be expected to be as careful as an adult, and so there is a higher standard that schools must reach to escape liability.

If a pupil wanders into an area that is out of bounds, and is therefore a trespasser, the school could still be liable for an accident that occurs. This can pose a great concern to schools, as the courts have found occupiers liable for accidents caused by out of bounds premises such as sky lights and fire escapes. However the standard that the school must meet is much lower than when a pupil is allowed on the premises, and essentially they only have to protect pupils from dangers that they are aware of or should reasonably be aware of.

Therefore in short, the courts do accept that sometimes pupils will suffer minor injuries at school and they should not be smothered in cotton wool. However this does not negate the fact that children can be seriously injured when under a school’s care, and should therefore be protected. Whether a school is liable for an accident will largely depend on the individual facts of the case, and parents should therefore contact a lawyer as soon as possible if they feel that their child has a potential claim.

Share this article


Related InsightsVIEW ALL

  1. man cycling past London underground station

    London Cycling Injury Case Studies

    Successful claim by cyclist injured after a hit-and-run Our client had been playing volleyball in the New Cross area of...

    Read more
  2. cyclist in camden, london

    Cycling Accident Claims: Client Stories

    GP Awarded £1m Settlement Kate Milton, a Senior Associate at Osbornes Law settled a cycling accident claim for a 52-year-old...

    Read more
  3. forklift truck

    £250,000 settlement for client injured in forklift truck accident

    Sophie Davies, a specialist personal injury lawyer at Osbornes Law, recently represented a client who suffered life-changing injuries following a...

    Read more
  4. Accidente en almacén

    Accident at Work Client Stories

    £20,000 for Industrial Injury Claim Enviro-Strip (UK) Ltd have been ordered to pay £20,000 in accident at work compensation after a worker...

    Read more
  5. road cyclists

    Do you have to wear a bike helmet?

    Should bike helmets be mandatory in the UK? Recently, Dan Walker was involved in a nasty collision with a motorist...

    Read more
  6. green traffic light

    Fatal Accident Case Studies

    Settlement for Pedestrian Killed Crossing the Road Laura Swaine, an Associate at Osbornes Law acted on behalf of a family...

    Read more
  7. Asian women holding a photo frame of lost loved one and crying.

    Bereavement Support Payment

    What are Bereavement Support Payments? Bereavement Support Payments are a benefit historically only available to parents whose husband, wife or...

    Read more
  8. shiba inu dog walking in the dark outdoors

    Claimant receives settlement after vicious dog attack

    The Claimant had been walking her two dogs on the lead, late at night, near to her home. As they...

    Read more
  9. stadium

    Pedestrian receives £1.75 million following amputation

    Kate Milton, acted on behalf of a Romanian National who was hit by a speeding vehicle as she was walking...

    Read more
  10. Rush hour in London

    Motorcyclist receives £3 million in settlement

    Kate Milton, a Senior Associate at Osbornes Law settled a claim for a 27-year-old motorcyclist who was involved in a...

    Read more

    Award nomination for catastrophic injury lawyers at Osbornes...

    The personal injury team at Osbornes are delighted to be finalists at The Personal Injury Awards 2022 in the category of ‘...

    Read more
  12. Cyclist on a street in London

    Cyclist Receives £50,000 After Hit by Sports Car

    Andrew Middlehurst, a lawyer in the specialist cycling injuries team at Osbornes Law, recently settled a claim for a cyclist...

    Read more
  13. accidente de bicicleta

    London cyclist struck by 4×4 receives settlement

    Andrew Middlehurst, a lawyer in the specialist cycling injuries team at Osbornes Law, recently settled a claim for a cyclist...

    Read more
  14. cars on portobello road

    Car accident client stories

    Below is a summary of the car accident claims that the personal injury specialists in the personal injury claims department...

    Read more
  15. bicycle wheel

    Injured London Cyclist Receives £70,000 Settlement

    Cycling accident lawyer, Laura Swaine, recently settled a claim for an injured cyclist who sustained serious injuries to her wrist...

    Read more
  16. highway code bike lights

    Top 10 Major Highway Code Changes for Cyclists

    New Highway Code rules for cyclists At the end of January 2022, the Highway Code was updated to make British roads...

    Read more
  17. E Bicycle

    Settlement reached for cyclist after insurers deny liability

    Personal Injury specialist, Laura Swaine, recently settled a cycling injury claim following the driver fleeing the accident site and refusing...

    Read more
  18. Ambulance

    Client left with brain injuries after car accident...

    Our Spanish client was the front-seat passenger in a car driven by her husband who was involved in a high-speed...

    Read more
  19. accidente de bicicleta

    £130,000 Settlement for Cyclist Struck by London Taxi

    Andrew Middlehurst, a specialist cycling injury lawyer, has settled a claim for a cyclist who was struck by a black...

    Read more
  20. 20.1.2022

    Cycling accident advice

    Now more than ever before, people are embracing the pleasures and benefits of cycling in and around London. Unsurprisingly, the...

    Read more
  21. doctor brain mri

    Settlement secured for head injury caused by hammer...

    Osbornes Law has secured a £100,000 settlement for her client who suffered serious head injuries after being attacked in prison by...

    Read more
  22. personal injury awards

    Ben Posford named catastrophic injury lawyer of the...

    Osbornes Law are delighted to announce that Ben Posford has been named as ‘Catastrophic Injury Lawyer of the Year’ at...

    Read more
  23. school children writing

    £270,000 settlement for school accident

    Osbornes Law secures a £270,000 settlement for a Polish woman who slipped as a schoolgirl on a wet floor at school....

    Read more
  24. shopping bags

    £100,000 settlement for tripping at work

    Osbornes Law secures £100,000 settlement for Hungarian woman who tripped over a shopping bag at work Siobhan McIvor, a Partner in...

    Read more