Supreme Court Hands Down Judgement in Mills v Mills

Joanne Wescott

Table of Contents

The Supreme Court today handed down judgement in the case of Mills v Mills, setting aside the order made by the Court of Appeal in 2017.

In August 2017 Mr Mills was granted permission to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal to increase his ex-wife’s spousal maintenance payments, fifteen years after they were divorced.

The facts of the case

Following their divorce in 2002, the parties’ financial claims were settled by a consent order which, amongst other things, provided the wife with a capital sum and required the husband to pay spousal periodical payments for the wife of £1,100 pcm for joint lives.

In 2014, the husband applied to discharge the periodical payments order or, in the alternative, reduce the payments due thereunder. His case was that the circumstances pertaining in 2002 had changed in that the wife (i) had lost the capital she had been awarded in 2002 through gross financial mismanagement and (ii) was now in a position to work (or work more) in order to increase her earnings. The wife made a cross-application for an increase in her periodical payments on the basis that she was unable to meet her basic needs. The judge held that the order should continue at the current rate without any variation. The Court of Appeal allowed the wife’s appeal and increased the maintenance payable by £341 pcm to £1,441pcm.

The decision

The Supreme Court reversed the decision made by the Court of Appeal and held that the original periodical payment of £1,100 pcm should stand.

Joanne Wescott, a partner in the family department at Osbornes who represented Ms Mills comments:

“Today’s decision does not bring about the end of spousal maintenance for the wife, unattractively described as a “meal ticket for life,” far from it.  The original spousal maintenance provision of £1,100 per month from 2002 remains intact. What the Supreme Court decided was that the £341 increase provided for by the Court of Appeal was wrong because it took into account an element of Ms Mills rent”.

Joanne continues:

“The Court would need to give very good reasons for making that kind of order i.e. that a spouse should fund the other spouse’s rental payment where that spouse had received a capital provision for re-housing. Ultimately the Court has a very wide discretion but in this case the duplication for housing need was a not a very good reason”.

Next steps

Either of the parties, can apply to capitalise the maintenance payments. This is where a husband pays to the wife a lump sum to effectively buy a clean break and end monthly payments.

You can read the entire judgement here.

Share this article

Contact

Contact us today

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you






    Insights about Divorce Financial SettlementsVIEW ALL

    1. two people walking
      22.3.2023

      Does it matter if you’re a breadwinner...

      When it comes to deciding how wealth is split, English courts do not discriminate based on your role within the...

      Read more
    2. couple holding hands
      16.3.2023

      Are trusts protected from divorce?

      Can trusts protect an inheritance from your spouse? A trust is a separate legal entity. Neither spouse owns its assets. ...

      Read more
    3. cube cafe camden
      16.3.2023

      Is a limited company protected from divorce?

      Is my spouse entitled to half of my business? If you are involved in running a limited company, then it...

      Read more
    4. man looking out
      16.3.2023

      How is a pension split in a divorce?

      Pensions and Divorce In a divorce, pensions are taken into account together with all other financial assets. Once all assets...

      Read more
    5. Camden house red door
      16.3.2023

      Who gets the house in a divorce?

      How is a house divided in a UK divorce? For most people contemplating divorce, one of the main concerns will...

      Read more
    6. Family divorce and division of propert
      6.10.2022

      How to set aside an order in financial...

      My ex-spouse didn’t tell the truth about their finances when we divorced, can anything be done? Can the financial...

      Read more
    7. pension pot
      30.8.2022

      Pension sharing on divorce

      What is the new procedure for pension sharing? Pensions are one of the biggest assets of a marriage, yet many...

      Read more
    8. woman hand open empty purse
      6.5.2022

      My ex has cut me off during divorce

      Can my spouse cut me off financially? Unfortunately, it is far too common that when a client says it’s...

      Read more
    9. Close up of african american man with calculator
      6.5.2022

      Divorce Loans

      How the Court views loans from parents during divorce A frequent issue in financial divorce cases is a loan from...

      Read more
    10. mesher order house
      5.5.2022

      Mesher Orders Explained

      What is a Mesher order? A Mesher Order allows the sale of the family home to be postponed in a...

      Read more
    11. husband signing decree of divorce
      11.4.2022

      Private Financial Dispute Resolution (FDR) for Divorce

      Private FDR helps divorcing couples reach a financial settlement Our specialist divorce lawyers are keen to ensure our divorcing clients...

      Read more
    12. 9.12.2021

      Negotiating financial settlements in divorce

      Costly and acrimonious divorces: a lesson in what not to do  If you’re determined to pursue your financial claims...

      Read more
    13. squirrel hiding assets
      16.11.2021

      Uncovering hidden assets in your divorce

      Hiding Assets During a Divorce As part of your divorce, you and your ex will have to agree on how...

      Read more
    14. 9.11.2021

      Case Law Divorce Settlement

      6 cases that shape your divorce settlement Part of what makes our divorce lawyers experts in their field is knowing what...

      Read more
    15. separate paths in the snow
      10.9.2021

      Does Divorce Revoke A Will?

      Divorce and Wills In the midst of a divorce or separation, it’s rare for couples to think about making...

      Read more
    16. court of appeal
      10.8.2021

      Beneficial Interest in Property

      Andrew Watson, a London-based divorce lawyer in our family department and Resolution accredited cohabitation lawyer, summarises the law in relation...

      Read more
    17. 27.4.2021

      Divorce in your 60s – The Financial Implications

      How common is a divorce in your 60s? The latest divorce figures from the Office of National Statistics (ONS) show...

      Read more
    18. 18.2.2021

      Tax and Divorce

      Tax implications for divorcing couples As the end of the Stamp Duty holiday looms on 31 March 2021, that is not the...

      Read more
    19. father with child
      6.4.2020

      Setting aside a financial remedy order

      What has been the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on financial remedy orders? Can you do it at all? Barder...

      Read more
    20. man and women at a table
      4.9.2019

      Calderbank Offers

      The Resurrection of Calderbank Offers When a couple divorces, they are encouraged by the Courts to consider other dispute resolution...

      Read more
    21. divorced man with empty wallet
      13.8.2019

      Bankruptcy and Divorce

      Will my spouse declaring bankruptcy affect my divorce settlement? The case of Hayes v Hayes (2012) EWHC (Ch) (Chancery Division (23.03.12) (unreported...

      Read more
    22. 25.3.2019

      Self-Help in Financial Remedy Proceedings

      One of the first things we explain to clients who are getting divorced is that, when it comes to financial...

      Read more
    23. kyance mews london
      25.3.2019

      Y v Y – Balancing inheritance, family wealth and...

      The recent case of Y & Y looks at how the Courts have been dealing with inherited assets and confirms...

      Read more
    24. 25.3.2019

      Effect of Delay on Financial Relief Claims: Vince...

      Wyatt v Vince This unusual case demonstrates the risks of failing to bring a financial claim on divorce promptly, or,...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL