Why safety improvements for the placement of nasogastric tubes are vital

The Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch has this month launched an investigation looking at the implementation of safety improvements for the placement of nasogastric tubes (NGTs).

What are nasogastric tubes?

NGTs are passed through the nose of the patient and then down the back of the throat, through the oesophagus to the stomach. They are used to give medication, food and drink to patients who are critically ill or unconscious, have suffered a neurological condition such as a stroke and so cannot swallow, or to patients whose conditions mean that they cannot take in enough food or drink by mouth to meet their nutritional needs. The placement of an NGT needs to be carried out by a medical professional who has had training in how to do so, and who is competent in assessing whether the tube has been correctly placed.

Serious Consequences of Misplacement

The investigation has come about after the HSIB was notified of an incident in which a patient had an NGT inadvertently inserted into his lung. Whilst the misplacement of these tubes by medical staff is thankfully a relatively rare event, the consequences of doing so can be catastrophic and even fatal, and so it is important that where improvements to safety can be made, these are identified and implemented.

Whilst in the above case the patient thankfully recovered after a period of treatment, I have recently been instructed in a case whereby the negligent placement of an NGT, and the failure to identify that is had been misplaced, led to the death of the patient. An investigation was commenced by the NHS Trust in question which identified a number of improvements which could be made in order to prevent such an incident from happening again.

In the case I referred to above, the NGT was placed into my client’s mother’s lung and there was a failure by the nursing team thereafter to identify this until she began to deteriorate. Feeding was commenced via the misplaced NGT and my client’s mother suffered a pneumothorax and aspiration pneumonia from which she was unable to recover. The report into her death identified a number of safety issues which contributed to this incident, including:

• Nursing staff not following the NGT protocol for the testing of NGT positions, due to a deficit in their education and training and confusion regarding the protocol;
• The Trust’s NGT protocol was not sufficiently clear as to when chest x-rays should be used to confirm NGT placement in patients with a low level of consciousness and who have recently been vomiting;
• A delay in the escalation of the patient’s deterioration and a delay by the medical team due to a breakdown in communication; and
•  Repositioning of the NGT after its partial removal by the patient, and a delay in recognising that the NGT had been misplaced, such that feeding was commenced before this was noticed.

It is clear that lessons can be learned from the errors which were made in this case, and which unfortunately have also occurred in other cases. It is important that medical staff who are frequently asked to place NGTs have access to teaching sessions regarding NGT placement and management, and that such sessions are repeated regularly enough so that staff are up to date with best practice.

Further, NGT policies in hospitals need to be clear and consistent. Policies should contain clear guidelines on PH testing (which is used to confirm correct placement), measurement of the tube, monitoring of the tube’s position and adherence to protocol.

HSIB Investigation

There have been attempts in recent times to mitigate the risks of misplacement of NGTs, following a number of safety alerts since 2005. However, as the case above demonstrates, there is still room for improvement. Misplacement of NGTs are classified as ‘Never Events’ within the NHS and so with improved practice there should be hope that such events can be eradicated entirely.

The HSIB investigation aims to look at the safety risks. They have committed to taking

“a human factors approach to understanding the processes, practices, interactions among people and other elements of system performance involved with the insertion of NGTs and confirmation of their position’.

This would appear to be a sensible approach given the issues with NGT misplacement and given the safety issues identified in the case I am currently working on, and the findings of the investigation will be of great interest to clinical practitioners as well as patient safety groups and lawyers.

The HSIB’s interim bulletin which was published on 5 February 2020 can be found here:

https://www.hsib.org.uk/investigations-cases/placement-nasogastric-tubes/

Blog post written by Medical Negligence Lawyer,  Nicholas Leahy