Positive Covenants and Successors in Title

Simon Nosworthy
golf course

Table of Contents

The decision in Churston Golf Club Ltd v Haddock [2019] EWCA Civ 544

Property lawyers will have been relieved by the Court of Appeal’s decision in Churston Golf Club Ltd v Haddock (2019) which determined that a fencing obligation in a conveyance was not an easement but a positive covenant and, therefore it could not bind successors in title.

In this case, Mr Haddock brought proceedings against the tenant of Churston Golf Club, adjacent to his farm. He claimed that there had been a breach of a covenant in a 1972 conveyance of the golf club land to “maintain and forever after keep in good repair…stock proof boundary fences or hedges along with such parts of the land… as are marked T inwards on the plan.”

Birss J agreed with Mr Haddock and determined that a fencing easement was created. As a result, the golf club owners were bound by this obligation even though they were not a party to the 1972 conveyance. It is long established that the burden of positive covenants cannot directly run with the land and therefore bind successors in title. However, this decision if it had stood would have an example of the Court trying to give effect to the original parties intention by characterising a positive covenant as a fencing covenant so that it binds successors in title.

The golf club appealed the decision on the basis that the obligation was simply a positive covenant and not a fencing easement and therefore it could not be enforced by the successors to the original parties. The Court of Appeal agreed with this analysis and determined that the golf club owners were not bound by the obligation and therefore were under no obligation to maintain the fence.

Property lawyers need to be alert to the fact that when creating a positive obligation which they intend should bind successors in title, appropriate wording needs to be included in the transfer to allow this.

FAQS

Is a purchaser a successor in title?

Yes, a purchase is a successor in title as long as they are buying the same interest in the property. For instance, if Mr Smith sold the freehold interest in his house to Mr Jones, then Mr Jones would be Mr Smith’s successor in title. But if Mr Smith granted a 99 year lease of his home to Mr Jones, then Mr Jones would not be a successor; he would be a tenant. A successor in title does not have to be a purchaser. It could also include an heir, liquidator, executor, trustee in bankruptcy or anyone who takes legal ownership of the property.

Can positive covenants be enforced?

Generally, you can pass the burden of positive covenants to new owners by putting some additional legal mechanisms in place. There are various ways of doing this. The most common way is for your solicitor to include language in the transfer confirming that the new owner will perform the positive covenant and will not sell the property unless they obtain a similar promise from the next purchaser.

What does successor in title mean?

A successor in title is anyone who takes over the legal ownership of a property from someone else. If Mr Smith sold his house to Mr Jones, then Mr Jones would be Mr Smith’s successor in title. If Mr Jones then sold the home to Mrs Brown, Mrs Brown would be a successor in title to both Mr Jones and Mr Smith. In theory, this chain of succession could go on forever.

Is a purchaser a successor in title?

Yes, a purchase is a successor in title as long as they are buying the same interest in the property. For instance, if Mr Smith sold the freehold interest in his house to Mr Jones, then Mr Jones would be Mr Smith’s successor in title. But if Mr Smith granted a 99 year lease of his home to Mr Jones, then Mr Jones would not be a successor; he would be a tenant.

A successor in title does not have to be a purchaser. It could also include an heir, liquidator, executor, trustee in bankruptcy or anyone who takes legal ownership of the property.

Can positive covenants be enforced?

Positive covenants can be enforced against:

  • The person who originally gave the positive covenant, and
  • A successor in title who has legally agreed to perform the positive covenant

Things get tricky when a property has changed hands many times, and you cannot be certain whether every single owner in the chain has signed an obligation to perform the positive covenant. In most cases, you won’t be able to force a successor in title to perform the covenant either, as you’ll only be able to obtain damages, not specific performance.

Covenant issues can be rather complicated, so it’s a good idea to take advice from a solicitor before doing anything to change the ownership of property.

Share this article

Contact

Contact us today

For a free initial conversation call 020 7485 8811

Email us Send us an email and we’ll get back to you

    • [utm_campaign_i][/utm_campaign_i]
      [utm_source_i][/utm_source_i]
      [utm_medium_i][/utm_medium_i]
      [utm_term_i][/utm_term_i]
      [utm_content_i][/utm_content_i]
      [gclid_i][/gclid_i]

    Related InsightsVIEW ALL

    1. House-Finsbury-Park
      19.5.2023

      Declaration of Trust for Property

      If you are buying a property jointly, you may want to consider making a declaration of trust to record your...

      Read more
    2. kensington apartments
      11.5.2023

      Lease Extension Negligence

      What is Lease Extension Negligence? Solicitors Negligence when a Tenant claims a new lease of a flat under the Leasehold...

      Read more
    3. tate modern london
      11.5.2023

      Overlooking Nuisance Claims

      Overlooking Nuisance Claims – net curtains not necessarily! I refer to the article https://law.wpstaging.uk/blog/overlooking-nuisance-claims-buy-some-net-curtains/ which concerned...

      Read more
    4. cars on portobello road
      11.5.2023

      Rent Repayment Order: Rakusen v Jepsen

      Rakusen v Jepsen & Others 2023 Judgement was given in this case on the 1st March 2023 and when it was settled...

      Read more
    5. 10.5.2023

      Leasehold Reform expected by end of 2023

      The government announced in 2021 the introduction of various leasehold reforms which will affect the leasehold system for properties in England...

      Read more
    6. kyance mews london
      13.2.2023

      Transfer of Equity Stamp Duty

      Do I Pay Stamp Duty Land Tax When Transferring Property into My Partner’s Name? When it comes to property...

      Read more
    7. apartments in london
      13.2.2023

      Shared Ownership Stamp Duty

      Do you pay stamp duty on shared ownership? When you buy a new shared ownership property, you are given two...

      Read more
    8. little venice in London
      8.2.2023

      Severance of a Joint Tenancy

      Severing a Joint Tenancy Normally, when couples buy a property together they do so as joint tenants. This means they...

      Read more
    9. camden lock
      8.2.2023

      Tenants in Common vs Joint Tenants

      Tenants in Common vs Joint Tenants: Which is best for buying a property together? When it comes to buying a...

      Read more
    10. Japanese Knotweed
      5.2.2023

      Japanese Knotweed: Knot in my backyard again!

      Many will have read the recent case in which a furniture designer pursued his seller successfully after he moved into...

      Read more
    11. door handle with a key
      20.1.2023

      Stamp duty tax to remain the same until 2025

      Good news for buyers as the current SDLT rates will remain until 2025 Buyers looking to purchase this year will be...

      Read more
    12. Concerned upset millennial couple
      19.1.2023

      Half of UK renters worried they will not...

      As rent rises for the majority of UK renters, half are worried they will not be able to afford it...

      Read more
    13. grand union walk camden
      23.9.2022

      First-time buyer stamp duty exemption – don’t get...

      Stamp duty is the bane of every home buyer, with only first-time buyers being exempt from paying the tax if...

      Read more
    14. london property
      9.6.2022

      TOLATA Claims

      What are trusts of land? Property ownership is not always a straightforward legal issue, particularly where the parties are cohabitees...

      Read more
    15. right to light
      8.6.2022

      Right to Light Law

      Right to Light Law in the UK Property owners have a legal right to light as set out in the...

      Read more
    16. flats in a london street
      8.6.2022

      Landlords and the Dangers of Rent-to-Rent

      Rent-to-Rent refers to the practice of landlords letting a whole property to a tenant (usually a limited company), which is...

      Read more
    17. accidente de construccion
      30.5.2022

      The uncertainties of beginning a building project now

      The construction industry is seeing a perfect storm at the moment with labour shortages following Brexit and material costs which...

      Read more
    18. A hand is holding a model house
      6.4.2022

      The End of Ground Rents

      The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 It has been confirmed that The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 will come into...

      Read more
    19. Low rise office building
      26.11.2021

      The new Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill

      On the 9th November 2021 the Government announced the new draft Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill. It is proposed that a new...

      Read more
    20. Green ecological house in empty field
      9.11.2021

      Can I still claim adverse possession?

      The principle of “adverse possession” commonly known as “squatters rights” is a principle which allows a person who does not...

      Read more
    21. party wall disputes
      5.10.2021

      Buying a property where a Party Wall Award...

      Buying a house with a party wall agreement Buying a property can already be a stressful process but finding out...

      Read more
    22. carnaby street london
      1.10.2021

      Commercial rent arrears options post-Covid

      Whilst we are reminded every day that Covid is very much still with us and that the public should still...

      Read more
    23. giving keys to couple
      24.9.2021

      First Time Buyers Tax Relief Reminder

      First-time buyers have been urged to make the most of a ‘forgotten tax relief’ that could save them thousands of...

      Read more
    24. 26.6.2021

      The Risks Of Buying Properties Off Plan!

      The Daily Mail reported recently that 300 families a week are having to move into shoddy newly built homes. Not all...

      Read more

    VIEW ALL